In This Article
When you need earwax removed, you want to know you're choosing the safest, most effective method. But with different techniques available—ear irrigation and microsuction being the most common—how do you decide which is right for you?
I'm not sure why this isn't explained more clearly to patients, but the truth is, both methods have their place. Neither is universally "better" than the other. What matters is finding the right approach for your specific situation, your ear health, and your comfort level.
At Earwax Removal Devon, we offer both microsuction and ear irrigation because we believe in tailoring treatment to the individual. Let's break down exactly how each method works, what the evidence says about safety and effectiveness, and how to choose the best option for you.
What is Microsuction?
Microsuction is a dry method of earwax removal. Think of it as a tiny, medical-grade vacuum cleaner for your ears. Here's how it works:
A specialist uses a binocular microscope or loupe magnification to look directly into your ear canal. They then insert a small suction tube—about the width of a pen refill—and gently remove the wax under direct vision. The whole process is controlled, precise, and doesn't involve any water.
The key advantage? The practitioner can see exactly what they're doing at all times. There's no guesswork, no flushing, and no need to soften the wax beforehand (though softening can make the process easier).
Microsuction has become the preferred method in many NHS and private clinics, particularly in ENT departments. It's considered the gold standard for wax removal in the UK, and for good reason.
What is Ear Irrigation?
Ear irrigation—sometimes called ear syringing, though modern irrigation is quite different from old-fashioned syringing—uses water to flush out earwax. Here's the process:
A controlled stream of body-temperature water is directed into your ear canal using an electronic irrigator. The water flows around the wax, loosening it and washing it out. The water and wax drain into a collection basin, and the process is repeated until the canal is clear.
Modern irrigation systems are much safer than the old metal syringes used decades ago. They use regulated pressure and temperature-controlled water to minimize discomfort and risk. However, unlike microsuction, irrigation is a "blind" procedure—the practitioner can't see inside your ear canal during the process.
Safety Comparison: What Does the Evidence Say?
Let's talk about safety, because this is where the two methods differ most significantly.
Microsuction Safety Profile
Microsuction is generally considered the safer option, particularly for people with certain ear conditions. Because it's performed under direct vision, the risk of accidentally touching the eardrum or ear canal wall is lower. The practitioner can see and avoid sensitive areas.
Potential risks with microsuction include:
- Temporary dizziness or vertigo (due to the suction creating pressure changes)
- Noise discomfort (the suction can be loud, though it's brief)
- Minor abrasions to the ear canal (rare, and usually heal quickly)
- Tinnitus (temporary ringing, usually resolves within hours)
Serious complications are extremely rare. A 2015 study published in the Journal of Laryngology & Otology found that microsuction had a complication rate of less than 1%, with most issues being minor and temporary.
Ear Irrigation Safety Profile
Ear irrigation is also safe when performed correctly by a trained professional. However, it does carry slightly higher risks in certain situations.
Potential risks with irrigation include:
- Perforation of the eardrum (rare, but more common than with microsuction)
- Otitis externa (outer ear infection)
- Dizziness or vertigo (from water temperature or pressure)
- Temporary hearing loss (if water becomes trapped)
- Discomfort or pain
The risk of eardrum perforation with irrigation is estimated at around 1 in 1,000 procedures. This is why irrigation is contraindicated (not recommended) for people with a history of eardrum perforation, grommets, or recent ear surgery.
A 2018 Cochrane review found that both methods are generally safe, but microsuction may have a lower risk of serious complications, particularly for at-risk patients.
Effectiveness Comparison: Which Works Better?
Both methods are effective at removing earwax, but they work best in different situations.
Microsuction Effectiveness
Microsuction is highly effective for:
- Hard, dry wax
- Impacted wax that's been present for a long time
- Wax removal in people with narrow or sensitive ear canals
- Patients with perforated eardrums or grommets
- Hearing aid users (no water means no risk to devices)
Studies show that microsuction successfully clears earwax in 90-95% of cases. It's particularly good for stubborn wax that hasn't responded to drops or other methods.
One limitation: very soft, sticky wax can sometimes be more challenging to remove with suction alone. In these cases, we might use a combination of suction and manual instruments.
Ear Irrigation Effectiveness
Ear irrigation is highly effective for:
- Soft to medium-consistency wax
- Wax that has been pre-softened with drops
- Patients who find the noise of microsuction uncomfortable
- Larger volumes of wax
Irrigation has a success rate of around 85-90% when wax has been softened beforehand. However, it's less effective for very hard, impacted wax that hasn't been treated with softening drops.
The British Medical Journal published guidance stating that irrigation should only be used after wax softening drops have been applied for 3-5 days. This significantly improves effectiveness and reduces the need for repeat procedures.
Comfort and Patient Experience
Let's be honest—no one enjoys having their ears cleaned. But comfort matters, and the two methods feel quite different.
Microsuction Experience
Most patients find microsuction comfortable, though it's not entirely sensation-free. Here's what to expect:
- A loud noise (like a vacuum cleaner) close to your ear
- A slight pulling or tickling sensation
- Possible brief dizziness if the suction touches certain areas
- The whole process usually takes 10-20 minutes
Some people find the noise unsettling, but it's over quickly. We can pause anytime if you need a break.
Irrigation Experience
Irrigation feels quite different:
- A sensation of warm water flowing in your ear
- Possible dizziness or disorientation (from the water movement)
- A feeling of fullness during the procedure
- Relief as the wax is flushed out
Many patients describe irrigation as more "natural" feeling, though others find the water sensation uncomfortable. The process takes about 15-30 minutes, depending on how much wax is present.
Who Should Choose Microsuction?
Microsuction is the better choice if you:
- Have a history of eardrum perforation or ear surgery
- Have grommets or ventilation tubes in place
- Wear hearing aids (no risk of water damage)
- Have a narrow or sensitive ear canal
- Have very hard, impacted wax
- Have had problems with irrigation in the past
- Prefer a "dry" method with no water
Microsuction is also recommended for people with certain medical conditions, such as immunosuppression or diabetes, where infection risk needs to be minimized.
Who Should Choose Ear Irrigation?
Ear irrigation may be more suitable if you:
- Have soft to medium-consistency wax
- Have used wax-softening drops for several days
- Find the noise of microsuction too uncomfortable
- Have a healthy, intact eardrum with no history of problems
- Prefer the sensation of water over suction
Irrigation is often a good first-line treatment for straightforward wax buildup in people with no ear health concerns.
Contraindications: When Each Method Isn't Safe
Microsuction Contraindications
Microsuction is generally very safe, but we'd be cautious or avoid it if you have:
- Active ear infection (we'd treat the infection first)
- Severe vertigo or balance disorders (suction can worsen symptoms temporarily)
- Extreme anxiety about the procedure
Irrigation Contraindications
Irrigation should not be used if you have:
- A perforated eardrum (current or previous)
- Grommets or ventilation tubes
- Recent ear surgery (within the past 6-12 months)
- Active ear infection
- Cleft palate (higher risk of water entering the middle ear)
- Previous complications from irrigation
If any of these apply to you, microsuction is the safer alternative.
What We Recommend at Earwax Removal Devon
At our clinic, we take a personalized approach. We don't believe in a one-size-fits-all method. Here's how we decide:
Initial Assessment
We start with a thorough examination using video otoscopy. This allows us to see the type, amount, and consistency of wax, as well as check for any ear health issues.
Patient History
We ask about your ear health history, any previous problems, whether you wear hearing aids, and your preferences.
Tailored Recommendation
Based on this information, we recommend the most appropriate method for you. In many cases, microsuction is our first choice because of its safety profile and effectiveness. However, if irrigation is more suitable for your situation, we'll explain why and ensure you're comfortable with the approach.
Combination Approach
Sometimes, we use both methods in the same appointment. For example, we might use irrigation to loosen softer wax, then microsuction to remove harder, impacted wax. This combination can be highly effective.
The Bottom Line: Which is Better?
Here's the truth: both microsuction and ear irrigation are safe, effective methods when performed by trained professionals. Microsuction has a slight edge in terms of safety and versatility, which is why it's become the preferred method in many clinics. However, irrigation remains an excellent option for many patients, particularly when wax has been softened beforehand.
What matters most is that you receive treatment from someone who is properly trained, uses the right equipment, and takes the time to assess your individual needs. At Earwax Removal Devon, we pride ourselves on offering both methods and helping you choose the one that's right for you.
Don't let earwax buildup affect your hearing and quality of life. Whether you need microsuction, irrigation, or a combination of both, we're here to help.
Book your appointment with Earwax Removal Devon today. We offer same-day appointments, professional assessments, and safe, effective wax removal using the method that's best for you.
